Last reviewed: October 2, 2026 · Reviewed by the BakingSubstitutes Editorial Team
Quick answer
For basic sauce, gravy or filling thickening, start with 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour for every 1 tablespoon cornstarch. If you have arrowroot or potato starch, use roughly 1 tablespoon for 1 tablespoon. Tapioca starch is commonly used at about 2 tablespoons per 1 tablespoon cornstarch. These are starting points; always check the recipe and adjust at the end, because starches differ in strength, clarity and how they react to heat and acid.
Substitute ratios and what changes
| Substitute | Amount for 1 tbsp cornstarch | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| All-purpose flour | 2 tbsp | Opaque, slightly cloudy result; must simmer a few minutes to lose the raw-flour taste |
| Arrowroot | About 1 tbsp | Glossy and clear; can turn thin or slimy if boiled hard or mixed into dairy |
| Potato starch | About 1 tbsp | Thickens at a lower temperature; best added near the end and not boiled long |
| Tapioca starch | Commonly about 2 tbsp | Clear, slightly stretchy or chewy texture; good in fruit fillings |
| Instant ClearJel (specialty) | Same amount, per King Arthur | Clear, stable filling; no cooking needed to activate |
Because brands and grinds vary, treat any ratio as a first pass. Add the minimum, simmer, and then thicken further in small increments rather than overshooting.
Why substitutes behave differently
Cornstarch is nearly pure starch. When granules are heated in liquid they swell and burst, a process called gelatinization, and the released starch molecules tangle into a gel that thickens the liquid. Wheat flour contains only a portion of starch, with proteins and other components making up the rest. That is why you need more flour for the same effect and why the finished sauce looks cloudier.
Different starches gelatinize at different temperatures and form different gels. Root and tuber starches such as potato, arrowroot and tapioca tend to give clearer, glossier results, but they can be less forgiving of prolonged boiling or vigorous stirring, which can break the gel back down into a thin liquid.
Sauces, gravy and soups
Flour works best here because the dish is already simmering and opaque. Make a slurry or a roux first so it does not clump.
- Whisk the 2 tablespoons of flour with about 3 to 4 tablespoons of cold water or broth until completely smooth.
- Pour it slowly into the simmering liquid while whisking.
- Keep it at a gentle simmer for at least 2 to 3 minutes so the starch fully swells and the raw flour flavor cooks out.
- Check the thickness. Sauces keep thickening as they cool, so stop slightly looser than your target.
For arrowroot or potato starch, use the same cold-liquid slurry, but add it at the very end and heat only until the sauce thickens. Cooking them longer is a common reason a sauce loses body.
Fruit pie fillings
Fruit fillings face three challenges: acid, long baking and juice release. High acid, as in cherries or rhubarb, can weaken starch gels over time, and watery fruit needs more thickener than a firm apple. Tapioca starch and arrowroot give a clear, bright filling, while flour gives a softer, more opaque set. If you plan to freeze the pie, tapioca and arrowroot tend to hold up better than cornstarch, which can turn slightly spongy after thawing.
Toss the fruit with the thickener and sugar before filling the crust, let it sit for 10 to 15 minutes, and bake until the juices bubble visibly through the vents. Starch only reaches full strength when the filling actually bubbles, and the pie then needs to cool for several hours to slice cleanly. King Arthur Baking has published side-by-side testing of several pie thickeners (linked below).
Custards, puddings and baking
In stovetop puddings, you need to bring the mixture to a gentle boil while stirring to fully activate the starch, whatever type you use; check your recipe and temper any eggs carefully. If the pudding includes eggs and you are also swapping those, see our egg substitute guide.
In cakes, cookies and shortbread, cornstarch is not a thickener but a texture tool. It replaces part of the flour so the dough contains less gluten-forming protein, giving a more tender, sandy or delicate crumb. If you are out, use the same volume of all-purpose flour in its place; expect a slightly firmer, less delicate result. Do not apply the 2-to-1 sauce ratio here, since that would add extra flour and make the bake dense.
Frying coatings and gluten-free cooking
Cornstarch gives fried foods a thin, crisp shell. Potato starch is a close alternative, and rice flour is often used for a light, crunchy coating. Plain flour will brown and crisp, but tends to be heavier and less brittle. Coat the food, shake off excess, and fry right away so moisture does not turn the coating pasty.
For gluten-free recipes, arrowroot, potato starch and tapioca starch are the usual choices, and flour is not suitable. Check labels, since cross-contact may be a concern for people who must avoid gluten strictly.
Common mistakes and fixes
- Lumps: the starch went into hot liquid dry. Always make a cold slurry first, or strain the sauce through a sieve.
- Raw, pasty flavor: flour was not simmered long enough. Keep it at a gentle simmer for a few more minutes.
- Thin sauce after boiling: arrowroot or potato starch was overheated. Stir in a little fresh slurry and heat just until it thickens.
- Gummy or too thick: too much starch. Whisk in a splash of warm broth, milk or water.
- Runny pie: the filling never bubbled or was cut too early. Bake until the juices bubble, then let the pie cool fully.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use baking powder instead of cornstarch?
No. Baking powder is a leavener, not a thickener. Even though some baking powders contain starch, adding it to a sauce would create bubbles and an off flavor rather than body.
Is flour or cornstarch stronger as a thickener?
Cornstarch. A common rule of thumb is that it takes about twice as much flour to match it, which is why recipes use a 2-to-1 swap.
Can I skip the thickener entirely?
Often yes. Simmering the sauce longer to reduce it, or mashing some cooked vegetables or beans into soup, can thicken without any starch.
Why did my arrowroot sauce turn slimy?
It was probably overheated, stirred too long, or combined with dairy. Use a lower heat and add it last, or choose flour or potato starch for creamy sauces.
Can I swap cornstarch one-for-one in a cake recipe?
Where the recipe calls for a small amount of cornstarch alongside flour, replacing it with the same amount of flour is usually fine, though the texture may be a bit less tender.